Jana Edwards, LCSW
  • Home
  • About Jana
  • Book
    • Read an Excerpt
  • Speaker
  • Treatment Method
  • Services
    • Fee Payment
  • Workshops For Therapists
    • Workshop Registration
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Uncategorized
  • The Seduction of Accountability

The Seduction of Accountability

When couples enter treatment, the goal of one or both partners is often to get the other to admit that they have disappointed, hurt or violated their partner in either a specific situation or in general within the relationship.  They are looking for some version of “I know what I did was wrong, I’m sorry I hurt you, and I promise not to do it again.”  They believe that, if they hear these words, the problem is over.  And they often expect their therapists to make this happen.

Conflict continues when one or both partners refuse to be held accountable in the specific ways their partner wants.  This is often perceived as “You don’t love me” or “I can’t trust you” or “You aren’t meeting my needs.”  The seduction of accountability in intimate relationships is built on a wish that relational problems can be resolved easily and that bypassing the nonconscious, neurobiological drivers of couple conflicts is possible.

This thinking is certainly understandable.  The concept of accountability is quite important in communal societies.  For social structures to function well, their members need to believe that they can depend on others to be accountable to the rules of the social group.  We need laws and those that enforce them to fend off societal chaos.

But applying the simplicity of accountability to an intimate relationship misses the point of most couple conflicts and robs the couple of the ability to experience the healing that their brains are attempting to supply.  Focusing on accountability shuts down curiosity about the role of each partner in their compulsively repetitive conflicts.  In addition, too much focus on accountability sets the stage for shaming, not usually a desirable outcome of couple therapy.  It’s not that accountability is wrong; it’s insufficient in couple treatment.

It is an interesting fantasy that simply hearing the “offender” say “I’m sorry” cures the relationship.  You may recall that two blog posts ago (“Tackling the Hard Work of Integration”) I repeated the story of a couple in which the husband had offered heartfelt apologies for 20 years for having been involved in an affair that was long over.  This produced no resolution because the needs of the wife’s brain to relive the rage of childhood trauma and the husband’s brain to relive childhood shame took precedence.  Both partners had to be held accountable for approaching their stalemate with genuine curiosity about what their brains were up to and seeking the right words to accurately describe the feelings they both brought to this dilemma, rather than stopping at apologies and mea culpas.

The only accountability that is inherent in Neurodynamic Couples Therapy is for both partners to be safe to the treatment, and if they don’t seem to be able to do that, to be curious about why not.  If danger to each other and to the treatment persists, it is the therapist’s job to guide an exploration of the childhood dramas being brought into the treatment that require reliving danger.

Next post:  Reliving danger

Uncategorized
Finding the Right Words

Website by Luminary Digital